Changes in Genealogical DNA Testing
Posted on November 5, 2025 Leave a Comment
Back in 2005, Francis Collins in his book The Language of Life: DNA and the Revolution in Personalized Medicine predicted that DNA testing for health was on the horizon within 10 years and that your doctor would routinely order DNA tests for you. That hasn’t happened as quickly as he thought, but companies like 23andme built their databases by offering medically relevant Direct to Consumer (DTC) DNA testing. 23andMe has a database of about 13 million and overall the top 4 companies: Ancestry DNA, 23andMe, My Heritage, and Family TreeDNA have over 53 million test kits. Some of those may overlap so roughly 40-50 million people have done DTC DNA testing.
My Heritage and Family Tree DNA and Gene by Gene
Several things have piqued my curiosity of late. As announced in 2024 “Family Tree DNA has been a valued partner and friend of My Heritage for well over a decade. Notably, since the launch of My Heritage DNA in 2016, Family Tree DNA’s in-house lab, Gene by Gene, based in Houston, Texas, has provided My Heritage with our DNA processing services.” And furthermore “Family Tree DNA customers can transfer their family trees to My Heritage, and to continue building them on My Heritage. Family Tree DNA users can now easily transfer their family trees to My Heritage for free, after providing consent on both Family Tree DNA and My Heritage.” More recently My Heritage announced in October that is was Upgrading Its DNA Tests to 2X Whole Genome Sequencing to be carried out by Gene by Gene. And then just days ago Family Tree DNA announced 30X Full Genome Sequencing. “The All-in-one bundle includes your genome data, health analyses, and reports” for $379 on sale. Not quite the $99 WGS testing that was anticipated a few years ago but getting closer.
The above collaboration and new offerings may be a sign of the health of these two companies under Gene by Gene. And their pivot to Health offerings is intriguing. I wonder whether at a future date their may be options to combine them. Who knows?
23andMe
Meanwhile in March 2025, 23andMe filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection and announced that the company was planning on selling substantially all of its assets. So its long term status is in question. Who will acquire the assets and will the data still be available to testers? Your guess is as good as mine. One of my favorite features at 23andMe was their Chromosome browser. No word on if it may come back. If sold would the genealogy component just be a casualty? So for now I can’t recommend 23andMe due to a high level of uncertainty. Sad because it has about 13 Million testers.
Ancestry
In 2019 Ancestry offered AncestryHealth® their vision “was to empower people to take action to address potential health risks identified in their genes and family health history.” Then in 2020 they suspended that offering and returned “to deepen our focus on family history, including AncestryDNA®, which remains an important part of our commitment to family history.” Ancestry has over 25 million tested and although the lack a chromosome browser are among the easiest to use especially for those already with a paid Ancestry subscription. It is also among the most expensive.
It looks like Ancestry’s focus will stay toward genealogy which is good news. It has the largest database of historical records with over 30 Billion. My Heritage has a bit more focus on International Records and has about 20 billion records.
Family Tree DNA
For now FTDNA remains the best place for YDNA and mtDNA testing if you plan on looking for matches. The shifting landscape of DNA test is hard to predict. Ancestry offered YDNA tests years ago and then abruptly stopped in 2014, as they pivoted to atDNA tests only. The earliest YDNA tests at FTDNA were 12 marker test whereas today a 37 Marker test is generally considered a minimum.
Recommendations
People always want to know the best company to test at. That depends on your reason for testing.
- If you already subscribe to Ancestry or MyHeritage, testing atDNA is a no brainer especially at sale prices starting at $29
- Chromosome Browsers are included at FTDNA, MyHeritage and Living DNA
- A nice feature of 23andMe and Living DNA is they give your broad mtDNA , and if male: your YDNA Haplogroup
- FTDNA is the project based place to test YDNA, both YSNPS and YSTRS
- MyHeritage may bring more European matches for those with recent ancestry from Europe or Israel
- Living DNA has a strong emphasis on UK testers that may appeal to those with recent UK ancestry
- Full sequence mtDNA, with matching, is at FTDNA
- FTDNA & Living DNA allow uploads from other companies
Given sales this month especially around Black Friday, you could test at Ancestry and MyHeritage for less than $70 and upload to FTDNA and swim in all 3 ponds. If you return your MyHeritage in 2026 you will get 2X WGS!
Where it all ends up in a few years—who know? In the meantime databases grow and prices come down. The Ancestral origins continue to be refined. Whether they are improved each iteration is widely debated.
Kelly Wheaton ©2025 All Rights Reserved
KENT The Garden of England Day Three Part Two: Faversham & Whitstable
Posted on September 2, 2025 Leave a Comment
We left Leed’s Castle for Whitstable a seaside town and the setting for the British TV detective series ‘Whitstable Pearl’ which I ended up watching after I returned home. First up is tour bus and our driver Tony.
Whitstable is full of shops, art galleries and places to eat oysters.


This was the site of the infamous Oyster Tasting by Charlotte that didn’t quite make it down.



The Duke of Cumberland hotel, Joyanne spotting me through the shop window and a few of the Beach huts.
Next stop was Faversham for a tour of the Shephers Neame Brewery. We had a bit of time to have a look about. In the following photo you can see the store front for the Brewery and on the far left you can barely see a tent set up for a street market. Since we had some free time I wandered down to have a look.

I had been looking for something for my friend Denise who couldn’t make the trip and I found it! A Crummles & Company enameled trinket box with a butterfly—which was her childhood nickname.
And then I spotted another one which I bought for myself. I had just been give the memoir “Raising Hare”, by my daughter for Mother’s Day. And finished it just before the trip. These are European Hares.


We have our own here in California. A photo of one from my back yard. They like to prune my plants at times!
Now back to our tour at Shephers Neame Brewery which was quite interesting, even though I am not a beer drinker.






I also couldn’t resist their collection of pub signs.



And the tasting.
And I found this chart quite interesting and comparable to similar ones for wine tasting
So whether you stop by for a tour or try their ales at your local pub, Enjoy!
We drove back to Leed’s Castle where we were to spend another night. We went out to eat at the nearby Park Gate Inn. We had a lovely meal and even though they were short staffed, Bamber, our waitress, took care of us to perfection! Then back to the Castle for another night’s sleep.



Whether day or night the gardens at Leeds Castle, put on a show.
Kelly Wheaton ©2025 All Rights Reserved
KENT The Garden of England Day Two Part Two & Day Three Part One: Leeds Castle
Posted on September 2, 2025 Leave a Comment

We arrived at Leed’s Castle in the afternoon for a two night stay. I had written a bit about Leed’s Castle in an earlier blog post here. Leed’s Castle is confusing for many a tourist, as it is not located in Leeds, Yorkshire, but rather near Maidstone in Kent. About the year 857, Leeds Castle was a Saxon castle built of wood on 2 islands, in the middle of the River Len. It was owned by the Saxon chief, Led or Leed, and was known as the Manor of Esledes. We drove in from the east past the golf course. The Castle lies in an idyllic setting on 500 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds. Although I am sure a “day visit” to enjoy many of the attractions is quite lovely, but for me the best parts of Leed’s Castle were revealed in the late evening and early morning hours when the grounds are only open to those staying there. We were to spend two nights here. My room, which was supposed to be shared I had to myself, and it was huge. In total there were 4 sets of window, 3 overlooking Culpeper’s Garden and one the Car park. Room, the view over the garden and the 3 upstairs windows on left were my room.
I couldn’t have been more pleased to have such a lovely view of the garden. This was the site of the original Kitchen Garden named after the family that owned the Castle in the 17th century. In 1980 it was transformed by the landscaper designer Russell Page into a beautiful formal garden with a central Wisteria tree. My grandparents had a similar one in, albeit smaller, in their garden when I was growing up. The garden with formal box hedges is chock full of roses, iris, allium, poppies and assorted perennials.
This first evening we had a stroll around the grounds, although the castle itself was closed to all but the people who were staying on the island. Dinner was at the Castle View Restaurant. The food and the view did not disappoint.
On the way back to our room I caught a quick photo of Chuck and Joan.
Off to a great night’s sleep but woke early, which gave me the opportunity to wander about the grounds before anyone else was up!

Magical colors of the early morning light.





After my morning scramble about the grounds seeing many of my beloved Rhododendrons and Exbury Azaleas. The Exbury azaleas weere hybridized in England but from American deciduous azalea species. I was off to breakfast at the Castle View Restaurant and then for a guided tour of the castle.





From the front entrance the size and grandeur is less visible than from a distance. Inside is a textural delight. A mix of old a new.





Leeds Castle was host for a significant Middle East summit in 1978 when U.S., Israeli, and Egyptian foreign ministers met eventually leading to the Camp David Accords between Egypt and Israel. This was originally set to happen in London, but was moved to Leeds Castle for security reasons. Summit room top below.

The Dining hall is the home to an “altar piece” dating to about 1410. It shows 7 saints, 6 of whom are women. The gouging of the saints’ faces may have occurred in 1539 following the dissolution of Dartford Priory, a Domincan Nunnery, which is thought to have been the altarpiece’s probable original home.
There is much more to see but I was particularly interested in the pieces designed by Stéphan Boudin (1888-1967) Interior designer to for Lady Baillie as seen in above. And know for designing the red Room at the White House for Jacqueline Kennedy. My Room at Leeds Castle was called the Boudin Room. Two pieces below designed by Boudin.


There’s lots more to see, but I will leave it to you to visit the castle and explore further. Next up are visits to the towns of Faversham and Whitstable!
Kelly Wheaton ©2025 – All Rights Reserved
Celtic Origins
Posted on September 1, 2025 Leave a Comment
Apologies to my faithful readers. I took a break after the death of my best genealogy friend, Jean to process what her life and loss means to me. I have found that I cannot be creative on demand, and must wait for inspiration and the imperative juices to flow. Sometimes all that it takes is a bit of curiosity and some serendipity.


PADEN YDNA
A few days ago I was revisiting my PADEN cousin’s Big Y DNA test. The Big Y that I and my cousin Malia sponsored back in 2018, is the gift that keeps on giving. PADEN is the maiden name of my paternal grandfather’s mother. You may recognize her from the diary that she kept and that can be found here under Mary ‘Lulu’s Diary’ entries. PADEN comes from the Irish surname Páidín, a diminutive of Pádraig (Patrick), which means “noble” or “patrician” or in the Scottish version also from a Gaelic pet form of the personal name Patrick. An alternative Mac Phaidein or Mac Pheadain, which means “son of Phaidin,” a name derived from the Gaelic Fáelán meaning “little wolf.” Our PADEN ancestor, John PADEN came from Northern Ireland, perhaps Coleraine to Maryland by 1798, when his daughter Nellie was born there. tmThe family settling in Funkstown, Washington County. In a desire to locate the PADEN family origins we finally resorted to YDNA.
As more ancient skeletons are discovered and their DNA sequenced we are getting closer and closer to recreating the paths our ancestors took. Not just in a genealogical time frame but deep back into history. I annotated this map from FTDNA for our PADEN Ancient Connections for my cousins. It lists 4 ancient remains that match our PADEN ancestors. I will insert a caveat from my friend Roberta Estes “These remains are probably NOT YOUR ANCESTORS, but definitely ARE your distant cousins.” We SHARE a common ancestor. Sometimes that common ancestor will not be discovered in the same area that our ancestors lived. However, in looking at the Ancient shared DNA matches it does give us a geographic area. Since this was the Viking Age it is likely that these were sea faring people who frequented the Isles.
Our PADEN’s complete SNP path from the R Haplogroup : M207>M173>M343>L754>L761>L389>P297>M269>L23>L51>P310>L151>P312>Z290>L21>S552>DF13>Z39589>DF49>Z2980>Z2976>DF23>Z2961>Z2956>Z2965>M222>Z2959>S658>DF104>DF105>ZZ87>DF85>S673>S668>FGC8740>DF97>FGC19851>FTA3893>FGC19846>FGC42106>FGC42105>BY202797>BY202928
Each one of these SNPS is a mutation that happened in the duplication process of a one Man’s YDNA at the time a germ cell was replicated. That germ cell became a sperm cell fertilizing an egg that carried the YDNA. All descendants of that man will retain that mutation. His father or brothers will not! Only direct patrilineal descendants. The SNP M222’s overall frequency is: 28% in Ireland, 13.5% in Scotland, 4.7% in England, 2.5% in Wales, 2.5% in France, 1.2% in Germany. It is considered a Celtic marker found at high frequencies among Celtic language speakers.
Below is a chart of the PADEN matching Ancient remains organized by when the SNP occurred that separated our branch from that of the subject’s remains.
| Name of remains | Location | Time frame of remains | Cultural group | Time branching occurred | SNP Split |
| Hvalba 24 | Hvalba, Faroe Islands | 100-1100 CE | Viking | 50 BCE | R-FGC12948 — R-Z2959 |
| Hofstaòir 127 | Hofstaòir, Iceland | 900-1300 CE | Viking | 50 CE | R-S658 |
| Ballyhanna 331 | Ballyhanna, Donegal, Ireland | 1031-1260 CE | Gaelic | 200CE | R-DF105 |
| Faroe 17 | Sandoy, Faroe Islands | 1500-1700 | Viking | 200CE | R-Y32646– R-ZZ87 |
MY ANCIENT DNA
Okay, but it didn’t stop there. I went looking for my autosomal DNA at Ancestry which lists me as 3% Icelandic. I have tended to ignore that, other than to note my Norwegian and Scottish ancestors, but with these Icelandic matches for PADEN it gave me pause. So I went digging at the other companies I tested and happened upon My Heritage’s tools for Ancient Origins. My Heritage added this Ancient Origins feature back in February 2025, but I had not explored it. The chart below shows me during the Iron Age with a close match with the reference populations. The earlier Bronze age is 54.2% European Farmer (6300-2800 BCE) and 45.4 % Western Steppe (3300-2600 BCE). Now all of these should be taken with a spoon full of salt but I found the 98.4% CELTIC fascinating. I never would have expected that!
However, maybe I should have. Going back to my pre-teen years I have been interested in Ancient History. And particularly the cultures considered back then, as primitive, whether they be Native American or Maori or Celtic. The fascinating overlap of their wisdom traditions often passed down in story telling and song spoke to me of something very different and grounding. They were not the dominant cultures that got to write their own histories, so I was often skeptical of what was written about them. Savages is an oft used term by the dominant culture—and it is meant to demean and degrade.
When I was a toddler I remember three large stones that my parents had purchased, and placed in our yard by crane. They were in the Japanese tradition and they were each about 3 feet long or wide. It was then my love of stones was cemented for life. And anyone who has traveled with me, knows how much I will go out of my way to visit a stone circle. Below are Stonehenge, Clava Cairns and Callanish.



Whether Art, Archaeology, History or Music the ancients call to me—so not a surprise that I fell in love with the ancient lore of Wales and tales of Arthur Pendragon and Llewelyn the Great. And later with the book and later TV series, Outlander. It isn’t just ancient stones, or bones, or ancient Springs, or the Tree of Life. It is this love of the natural world expressed in ancient things. It is neither new, nor superficial. Their age and ability to endure, is somehow comforting. The following photos of Llewelyn the Great’s (1173 –1240) Castell Y Bere, near Llanfihangel-y-Pennant, Wales, taken in 2005 hint of such things.



And then there are the symbols of the Celts and later the Vikings that drew me into their spirals and animal motifs. In 2016 my friend and I planned a trip to Scotland and as preparation I read Peter May’s Trilogy set in the outer Hebrides and Adam Nicholson’s ‘Sea Room’. As luck would have it the ‘Celtics Art and Identity’ exhibit, that was first on display at the British Museum, was to be at the National Museum of Scotland during our visit. All a long winded way of saying an interest became a passion. And it was helped along by my husband’s YDNA which is of Celtic origin. And reading Peter May’s ‘The Chess Man’ I became acquainted with the Lewis Chessman carved of Ivory. Which I was able to view half of them at the National Museum of Scotland in 2016 and the other half this year (2025) at the British Museum, [my principal reason for going there]. These 12th century Ivory pieces I find enchanting. [Those below are a Queen, a Beserker and a King at the Museum of Scotland. Although a smaller collection, perhaps finer pieces.]



DO WE HAVE A CHOICE?
In reflecting on this unlikely journey I remembered a friend from the early days of 23andme and DNA Forums. She was an older African American woman and she shared with me her story of having taken German back in high school. Her friends gave her a hard time about it. And yet years later when she was married to a military man and stationed in Germany, she joined the German opera. She loved all things German and had no reason for it. Then she got her early DNA results and she was significantly German. In his book ‘The Horse, the Wheel and Language’ by David Anthony he writes:
“When you look in the mirror you see not just your face but a museum. Although your face,
in one sense is your own, it is composed of a collage of features you have inherited
from your parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, and so on.
The lips and eyes that either bother or please you are not yours alone but are features of your ancestors,
long dead individuals but still very much alive as fragments in you.
Even complex qualities such as your sense of balance, musical abilities, shyness in crowds
or susceptibility to sickness have been lived before.
We carry the past around with us all the time, not just in our bodies.
It lives also in our customs, including the way that we speak. The past is a set of invisible lenses we wear constantly, and through which we perceive the world and the world perceives us.
We stand always on the shoulders of our ancestors,
whether of not we look down to acknowledge them.”
And so I choose to believe that we are attracted to the ancient through the pull of the ancestors. The echoes of lives long since erased from the earth that we carry in our DNA. This book shelf is a testimony to them.

When I started my Celtic journey I suspected I might be maybe 25% Celtic and perhaps that is still true—but the significance of the Celts to me is great. Not to diminish other stories or cultures, as they are all valuable and very much intertwined.
This last photo is of a boss in the church of St Pancras at Widecombe on the Moor in Devon, England. It is likely an original from the 15th century. It is of 3 hares where their ears create a triangular pattern. Hares are sacred in the Celtic tradition, symbolizing prosperity, fertility and rebirth. The three-hare motif is in Christian parlance seen as a sign of the holy trinity. However its roots are in Buddhist China and likely spread along the Silk Road to Europe and was adopted by the Celts. It is often seen in the vicinity of the Green Man in old churches.
A couple of years ago I wrote this piece on the Winter Solstice and the Celts, in case you are interested.
Thank you for indulging me. I hope to get back to my tour of Kent, England soon. hopefully this little detour has primed the pump.
Kelly Wheaton ©2025 – All Rights Reserved














































